Question

[janus]

Would you accept a low scoring Pirates! Gold review?

EDIT: I think I posted this in the wrong forum...

[Melf]

Moved!

Why would you score it low?

[GeckoYamori]

Low scores are strictly forbidden!

[Melf]

Lol, it's not that. I'm just asking what he found poor about the game.

[janus]

Well I already wrote the review:

http://www.honestgamers.com/systems/content.php?game_id=3684&console_id=11&review_id=3752

But every other Sega fan seems to love this game so maybe I won't submit it. I can just moan about it in a Reader Roundtable!

[Melf]

I've no problem with the score, as the reviewer has the right to score the game as he/she sees fit. The only score I question is a perfect 10, which was being tossed around to freely for a while. Thankfully, that's been brought under control.

That's a great review Janus, and the only issue I'd have with it is that it's been posted at Honest Gamers already. I worked with Jason on Hardcore Gamer Magazine and don't feel right using stuff already posted on his site. Should you write something new and want to submit it to both sites, then that's different, since it hasn't already been posted somewhere first.

I want to get away from using previously posted content (which we've been doing for some time now) and have as much original material as possible. So feel free to rip Pirates! Gold a new on in the next Reader Roundtable! :D

[janus]

Okay, that's cool.